The Cabinet Office will have to give a new Freedom of Information response after it wouldn't hand over information about the Area Plan for the North and West.
Information Commissioner Dr Alexandra Delaney-Bhattacharya says the government redacted information after being asked for specific documents regarding the blueprint for Island development.
It had already provided more information after an internal review.
But the ICO says it didn't properly consider data protection principles, and lacked evidence it had considered what it called vexatious elements.
It must now re-process the request and provide a new response.
One-way Mountain Road opens - but not to cyclists
Scientist announces run for Onchan Keys seat
Fog and mist could disrupt flight schedules, says airport
Bottleneck parking "limited" during TT, says council
Dispose of your vapes properly, say firefighters
Play equipment review for Onchan
TT's fastest woman "gutted" to miss festival after crash
Merseyside Police launch TT bike safety operation