The Tynwald Commissioner for Administration says the Department of Environment, Food and Agriculture should reconsider refusing to allow a cancer sufferer to fell a tree on their property.
The householder complained after their application was refused, claiming the tree's roots were damaging their home.
Advocate Paul Beckett said DEFA hadn't considered the condition of the property's drive properly, which he found to be procedural maladministration.
In a report due to be laid before Tynwald during its March sitting, he recommended the department reviewed its decision made in November 2024.
10-day bus strike from next weekend
Yellow snow warning issued by forecasters
Ramsey harbour keeper completes 3,000-Mile Atlantic crossing
Higher ground could see overnight snow
Investigators say fatal Manx ship sinking 'avoidable'
Family's appeal to bring brain-injured dad home
Island animal charity appeals for help after relentless bad weather
Further appeal for witnesses following incident in Ramsey