Procedures were not properly followed and the project was "mishandled" - that's the damning verdict of £285,000 worth of work to dredge Peel Marina.
The findings of a Standing Committee, which was looking at the procurement of the dredging work, will go before Tynwald this month - it claims there were "significant errors".
Michael MHK Alf Cannan is the chairman - he says the failings are clear:
The Minister has claimed the department only made "two tiny mistakes" but the committee says it takes a different view - a debate on the topic is expected in March, something Mr Cannan welcomes:
Island to get branch of Palestine Solidarity Campaign
New government whistleblowing policy still up for discussion
Top TV magician to visit Island next week
New mapping shows risk from radioactive gas around Island
Manx Care sees sharp rise in complaints
Ben-my-Chree trialling Northern Ireland route
Parts of Braddan to be without water tonight
Hop Tu Naa Festival to kick off in Cregneash this weekend