Douglas Council has been told to rethink its response to a Freedom of Information request.
Someone wanted information about building control checks at the former Nurses Home development on Westmoreland Road.
But the local authority refused to provide details, saying it was exempt and releasing it would reveal trade secrets.
However, Information Commissioner Dr Alexandra Delaney-Bhattacharya said the exemption hadn't been applied properly, adding the council must now re-process the request and provide a new response.
Marquee plan submitted by Milntown Estate
Fire crews called to free driver from crashed car
Manx Museum celebrates 10 years of UNESCO Biosphere status
Volunteer wanted to help monitor Island's prison
MHK asks if families should get help with UK parole travel costs
Peel RNLI honoured for lifesaving actions at sea
Plans submitted to turn former offices into homes
Island has just 20 vacant homes for public tenants