The Tynwald Commissioner for Administration says it's not his place to say whether it would be better to demolish the Castletown Golf Links Hotel.
Advocate Paul Beckett's report into the row between a developer, local residents and Malew Commissioners will be laid before Tynwald in December.
Langness Golf Course Limited, which bought the hotel in 2011, complained that the local authority had failed in its duties because it hadn't ordered the building demolished.
However, Mr Beckett said that decision wasn't unreasonable - but said Malew Commissioners needed to be more transparent.
Weather warning for storm Dave this weekend
Roads to close for music festival this weekend
How long do mental health patients stay in Manannan Court?
Could you take over this former restaurant?
Framework of new Sea Services Agreement ready, says minister
Attorney General says he's stepping down
Road closures in two towns for running event this week
Six weekend ferry crossings could face disruption