The government says it's paying the UK around £3.3 million a year - but it's not sure what it's getting for its money.
A freedom of information request to the Cabinet Office asked for details about the Island's 30 year old agreement to make payments for defence.
In its response, the government said last year it paid £3,379,750 to the UK, up just under £80,000 on the year before.
But it added there's no list of what the payments fund - except they're in recognition of defence and other common services provided by the UK.
Richmond Hill closed again tonight for work
October warmer and sunnier than usual, says Met Office
MHK queries cost of Liverpool awards trip
DOI says it has 20 empty public sector homes
Marquee plan submitted by Milntown Estate
Fire crews called to free driver from crashed car
Manx Museum celebrates 10 years of UNESCO Biosphere status
Volunteer wanted to help monitor Island's prison