The Department of Infrastructure has questioned a number of statements made in the draft report about the Island's heritage railways.
Systra have conducted a review of the service and produced the report, which was sent to the DOI.
Chief Officer Emily Curphey replied with 15 comments and proposed changes, according to emails released in response to a freedom of information request.
She says the department has 'considerable concerns' about the claim that 15% of tourists would reduce their stay on the Island by one night, should the rail service be withdrawn.
The email also implies that assumptions were made in certain areas of the report, and there was a lack of information that the DOI expected to be included.
The full report has not yet been published.
Ballakilpheric Road shuts tomorrow
Peel Carnival needs you!
Commissioners looking for new clerk
Nobody charged for paper Manx Utilities bills, says chair
Should cohabiting couples get married tax breaks?
Repairs on Peel Power Station to get underway
Manx Care doctor survey to be discussed by Tynwald
Weather warning for snow tonight