Graham Linehan cleared of harassment but guilty of criminal damage to trans activist's phone

Father Ted creator Graham Linehan has been cleared of harassment against a trans activist but guilty of criminal damage to their phone.

The 57-year-old comedy writer, who had faced trial at Westminster Magistrates' Court, denied both charges linked to posts made on social media and a confrontation at a conference in London in October 2024.

Summarising her judgment, District Judge Briony Clarke started by saying it was not for the court to pick sides in the debate about sex and gender identity.

She said she found Linehan was a "generally credible witness" and appeared to be "genuinely frank and honest", and that she was not satisfied his conduct amounted to the criminal standard of harassment.

The judge said she accepted some of complainant Sophia Brooks' evidence, but found they were not "entirely truthful" and not "as alarmed or distressed" as they had portrayed themself to be following tweets posted by the comedy writer.

While Linehan's comments were "deeply unpleasant, insulting and even unnecessary", they were not "oppressive or unacceptable beyond merely unattractive, annoying or irritating", the judge said, and did not "cross the boundary from the regrettable to the unacceptable".

However, she did find him guilty of criminal damage, for throwing Brooks's phone. Having seen footage of the incident, the judge said she found he took the phone because he was "angry and fed up", and that she was "satisfied he was not using reasonable force".

The judge said she was "not sure to the criminal standard" that Linehan had demonstrated hostility based on the complainant being transgender, and therefore this did not aggravate his offence.

He was ordered to pay a fine of £500, court costs of £650 and a statutory surcharge of £200. The prosecution had asked the judge to consider a restraining order, but she said she did not feel this was necessary.

What happened during the trial?

The writer, known for shows including Father Ted, The IT Crowd and Black Books, had flown to the UK from Arizona, where he now lives, to appear in court in person.

He denied harassing Brooks on social media between 11 and 27 October last year, as well as a charge of criminal damage of their mobile phone on 19 October outside the Battle of Ideas conference in Westminster.

The trial heard Brooks, who was 17 at the time, had begun taking photographs of delegates at the event during a speech by Fiona McAnena, director of campaigns at Sex Matters.

Giving evidence during the case, Linehan claimed his "life was made hell" by trans activists and accused Brooks, a trans woman, of being a "young soldier in the trans activist army".

He told the court he was "angry" and "threw the phone" after being filmed outside the venue by the complainant, who had asked: "Why do you think it is acceptable to call teenagers domestic terrorists?"

Brooks told the court Linehan had called them a "sissy porn-watching scumbag", a "groomer" and a "disgusting incel", to which the complainant had responded: "You're the incel, you're divorced."

The prosecution claimed Linehan's social media posts were "repeated, abusive, unreasonable" while his lawyer accused the complainant of following "a course of conduct designed both to provoke and to harass Mr Linehan".

Read more from Sky News:
BBC board members face MPs
Woman wakes up in coffin at crematorium

Following the judgment but ahead of sentencing, Linehan's lawyer Sarah Vine KC said the court "would do well to take a conservative approach towards the reading of hostility towards the victim".

She said the offence of criminal damage involved a "momentary lapse of control", and was part of the "debate about gender identity, what it means".

Vine said it was important "that those who are involved in the debate are allowed to use language that properly expresses their views without fear of excessive state interference for the expression of those views".

She also said the cost of the case to Linehan had been "enormous", telling the court: "The damage was minor; the process itself has been highly impactful on Mr Linehan."

She requested he be given 28 days to pay the full amount.

(c) Sky News 2025: Graham Linehan cleared of harassment but guilty of criminal damage to trans activist's phone